New Year, New Mindset: Avoid These 5 Traps That Derail Progress

Listen to the Episode Now:

(If player is taking a while to load, just refresh the page. You can also read the episode if you keep scrolling down.)

Add the show to your podcast library on Apple (iPhone) Here or Spotify Here.

Listen to These Too:

• RELATED EPISODE: Mindset Shift for the Most Impactful Weight Loss Goal
• RELATED EPISODE: 5 Mindset Shifts to Make Changing Your Eating Habits Easier

Tired of struggling with the same bad eating habits?

I can help you transform your eating habits and lose weight sustainably in my 1:1 coaching program, Eat with Intention, Lose Weight Sustainably.

Imagine going through your day feeling healthy, confident and free.

Why delay feeling your best yet? Book your free 60-min. consultation with me now.

Enjoying the Show?

Help make the show more discoverable to others who are frustrated with their eating habits by leaving a rating/review.

Just use the links below (or go right onto the app you normally listen on). Thank you!

• Rate/review on Apple (iTunes) HERE
• Rate on Spotify HERE

Know someone who’d benefit?

Just send them a text with a link to this page.

Read the Transcript:

New Year, New Mindset: Avoid These 5 Traps That Derail Progress

Hi there, and welcome to the Eating Habits for Life podcast! Today, you and I are diving into a topic that’s especially relevant as we step into the New Year: mindset traps that can derail your progress and how to avoid them. If you’ve ever set a New Year’s resolution and found yourself struggling to stick to it, this episode is for you.

We all know the New Year brings this incredible energy of fresh starts and big goals, and while that’s exciting, it can also be overwhelming, especially after that initial excitement.

What I’ve found in my own life and through coaching is that the missing piece in most resolutions isn’t willpower or even motivation—it’s mindset. If your mindset isn’t in the right place, even the best intentions can fall apart.

So today, I’m here to help you identify five common mindset traps that can sabotage your progress and, more importantly, how to overcome them. We’ll talk about everything from all-or-nothing thinking to comparison traps, and I’ll give you actionable tips to make 2025 the year of sustainable progress, not perfection. Let’s jump in!

Mindset Traps and Solutions

Trap #1: All-or-Nothing Thinking

Let’s start with one of the most common traps: all-or-nothing thinking. This is the belief that if you can’t do something perfectly, it’s not worth doing at all.

For example, you might think, “I had one cookie, so I’ve ruined my whole day. I might as well eat the rest of the box.” Sound familiar? And you might not really be aware you’re consciously having this thought, but your actions can be the thing that alerts you.

The problem with this mindset is that it leads to self-sabotage. One small misstep can snowball into a full-blown derailment, and it doesn’t have to be that way.

The solution? Progress over perfection. One choice does not define your entire day, week, or journey. Instead of throwing in the towel, practice saying, “I made one choice that wasn’t the most ideal, but I can make a better choice next time.”

Here’s a practical tip: When you catch yourself in all-or-nothing thinking, or the actions that suggest all-or-nothing thinking, take a deep breath and ask, “What’s the next best thing I can do for myself right now?” That small pivot can make all the difference.

Trap #2: The “I’ll Start Over Monday” Mentality

The second trap is the “I’ll start over Monday” mindset. This happens when you delay action, waiting for a perfect time to restart. Maybe it’s Monday, the first of the month, or even next year.

Here’s the problem: There’s never a perfect time. Waiting only creates a cycle of inconsistency, where you keep delaying your progress. The truth is, every moment is an opportunity to restart.

The solution? Treat each decision as a fresh start. You don’t have to wait for Monday or the New Year. Progress happens in small, consistent actions.

A practical tip here is to focus on what you can do right now. Ask yourself, “What’s one small thing I can do to move forward today?” Maybe it’s drinking a glass of water, going for a walk, or planning your next meal. Small actions create momentum.

How I help my clients overcome bad eating habits, form healthier ones and lose weight sustainably consists of a lot of small changes that are doable and fit in well to their specific circumstances, that they keep building on over time. It works incredibly well.

Trap #3: Fear of Failure or Judgment

Next up is the fear of failure or judgment. This is the voice in your head that says, “What if I try and fail?” or “What will people think of me if I don’t succeed?”

This mindset trap can be paralyzing. It keeps you from taking action because you’re so focused on the worst-case scenario. But here’s the truth: Not following through on an intention can be seen as a bump in the road, not the road just completely ending. It isn’t the opposite of success…it’s part of it. Every mistake or missed intention is an opportunity to learn and grow.

To overcome this trap, start reframing failure or mistakes. Instead of thinking, “I failed,” try saying, “I learned something valuable.” And as for judgment, remind yourself that other people are often too busy worrying about their own lives to focus on yours.

Here’s a tip: Take a few minutes to journal about past challenges you’ve overcome. Reflect on what you learned and how it made you stronger. This can help build your confidence and shift your focus from fear to growth.

Trap #4: Unrealistic Expectations

Trap number four is setting unrealistic expectations. This might look like deciding you’re going to lose 20 pounds this month or completely overhaul your eating habits overnight. Now, I’m all about setting really big goals, also known as dream goals. However, being more realistic on time frame.

I mean, it’s possible you could lose 20 lbs in a month, but is this sustainable? It might be best to set a goal of losing 20 lbs. in 3 or 4 months. I mean the reality is, 2 years from now, will you really be upset that you lost the 20 lbs. in 3 or 4 months versus 1 month? No, not likely at all.

While ambitious goals can be motivating, they can also set you up for disappointment and burnout. Change takes time, and it’s important to set yourself up for sustainable success.

The solution? Set those dream goals in addition to smaller, achievable goals, plus celebrate your progress along the way. Instead of focusing on the big end goal, ask yourself, “What’s one small step I can take this week?”

Here’s a fun tip: Create a “success jar.” Every time you hit a small milestone, write it down on a piece of paper and put it in the jar. On tough days, revisit those notes to remind yourself how far you’ve come. Or you can do this in a little mini notebook. I’ve done this before. It’s fun to randomly open it up and read some of the things from weeks or months ago.

Trap #5: The Comparison Mindset

Finally, let’s talk about the comparison mindset. This is when you find yourself thinking, “Why can’t I lose weight as fast as she did?” or “Why do I struggle when it seems so easy for others?”

Comparison is the thief of joy. It shifts your focus outward, making you feel discouraged and inadequate. But here’s the thing: Your journey is unique. Comparing yourself to others only distracts you from your own progress.

The solution? Focus inward. Celebrate your wins, even what seem like tiny ones, and remind yourself that progress is personal.

A practical tip: Limit your time on social media, especially if certain accounts trigger unhealthy comparisons. Consider unfollowing or muting accounts that don’t align with your values or make you feel less than.

Shifting the Mindset for a Fresh Start

Let’s shift gears and talk about how to set yourself up for success in 2025.

Intention Over Resolution

Instead of setting rigid resolutions, focus on intentions. Intentions are rooted in how you want to feel or live, not arbitrary numbers. For example, instead of saying, “I need to lose 10 pounds,” try, “I want to feel energized and confident in my body.”

The Power of Small Changes

Sustainable change comes from micro-changes, not drastic overhauls. Start small—drink one more glass of water a day or add one vegetable to your meals. These tiny shifts add up over time.

Embracing Self-Compassion

And finally, be kind to yourself. Self-compassion is the secret ingredient to consistency. When you hit a bump in the road, instead of beating yourself up, remind yourself that you’re human. Progress is not linear, and that’s okay.

Additional Key Points to Take Home

As we wrap up, I want to remind you that mindset shifts don’t happen overnight. They take practice, patience, and a lot of self-compassion. But with each small change, you’re building a foundation for lasting success.

You’re capable of so much more than you give yourself credit for. Don’t let these mindset traps hold you back. You have everything you need to make 2025 your year of progress, not perfection.

If you’d like personalized support, I’d love to help. You can book a free consultation to explore strategies tailored to your specific struggles and goals. I help with mindset, managing emotions that affect actions, the actions themselves, and how to use your results to keep the momentum going.

Transforming your eating habits isn’t just about what you’re eating or how much. It’s why you’re eating and why it might be challenging for you to stick to your intentions. And then focusing on solving for those, which then of course affects what you’re eating and how much. It’s learning skills, not being given a meal plan and told to follow it.

Alright my lovely listeners, here’s to a fresh start and a fantastic year ahead. Thanks for listening, take care and I’ll talk with you soon.